Jimmie is cool.

Love this podcast! A coworker told me to listen and I’m so glad I did! It makes the work day go by quickly.

I can’t believe it took me this long to listen to this pod. I love these guys! I can rarely get through an episode without laughing out loud. Will be binging every episode ✨

I never thought I’d love two random men in their 40s so much

Love you Jimmy, but please speak up! I want to hear what you're mumbling. 😅

This is truly what gets me through my workday!

Loving the fact that nobody is off-limits if they do something monumentally stupid—these guys go after everyone, from moronic criminals to unforgivably lazy/incompetent law enforcement professionals and prosecutors.

Love you both. But Jimmy W your honesty about everything you’ve been through in your life, what’s in your head, you have given a person someone to look up to and love. Thank you so much.

Bowties, beach balls, and banana hammocks.

Best podcast ever

I love listening to this podcast. Always a good listen, good laugh, crazy story.

I’m Ted. Here’s my Johnson.

Best podcast. I’ve listened to while working keeps me entertained.

Absolutely love listening to these guys. I love Jimmie’s laugh it get me every time. My favorite podcast to listen to I’m so glad I found these guys!!!💜💜💜

“Snakes have no arms. That’s why they don’t wear vests.”

AND GIVE ME MURDER! Favorite jelly is strawberry but the real fancy kind

I’m late to the party and am on episode 17. Absolutely loving this podcast. You guys are great!!!

Even though I wish I found this pod sooner, I’m so glad I have years of episodes to listen to at work, as a dog groomer, the pups look at me funny when I laugh out loud which happens often 😛

the 2026 GG are going to be handing out an award for best podcast. i definitely think this one should be nominated!

Love this podcast. I listen to it everyday at work! Funny and great murder stories 🙌🏻

I wrote a review before but turns out I just don’t know how this app works lol. It’s a great show, they’re very respectful of the people they talk about other than the killers but it’s in a tasteful way. Very funny and great to listen to while going about your day!

Come to FL for live show

I love the reviews portions if the show and then i came here and read the one star ratings and i don’t know if those people know exactly what they did but the layering up to add some laughs by giving a ridiculous review on a show that reads ridiculous reviews is very meta.

Jimmie is comedy gold

Yep

Very funny hosts! Great comical twists to light the otherwise dark and sometimes very disturbing genre of true crime. Great humor throughout the episodes, but make sure to listen to the shoutouts at the end of all of the full length episodes. Jimmy stumbling over the pronunciation of names ends up being some of the most entertaining material of the episodes, in my opinion.

This show just gets better with time

Wow.. the massacre. I would leave. Great story. Thank you.

Not a fan of the “comedy” narrative of the show. I worked and lived in Morenci for a few years, and the picture they paint of this town is so far off from the truth. I also worked with Matthew, so hearing the way they joked about a story that was tragic was offsetting.

My absolute favorite podcast!! I’ve been listening to James and Jimmy consistently since 2019!

Your episode from 04/03/24 taking place in wheeling, WV just wanted to comment that I was locked up with the female from that episode. It’s crazy hearing about the crime through the lens of researchers and investigators compared to hearing it be told by one of the actual suspects.

I work in cannabis and 420 has lost a little of its magic over the years. I spent weeks prepping and then all hands on deck the week of. Then we spend weeks trying to forget about it - similar to the holidays with your family you know? Like it’s fun… until it’s not. I completely forgot about the live show and my faith in 420 has now been restored. This is exactly what I needed, costumes are epic, we should do this quarterly at least. Thank you guys, huge fan!!

The best keeps getting better

Love the show and the laughs!

Seriously - 10/10

You’ll get it if you listen long enough. James and Jimmie are the best, the jokes make my day, everyday…seriously. Love you guys!!

Love this podcast! Listen to it most of the day! Comedy and true crime for sure belong together.

Great show. Keep doing what you’re doing!

If you can get past the extremely cheesy intro, disclaimer, and the 90s shock jock DJ modulated voice with Pietrogallo…this is a highly entertaining show and I love it. The stories are insane and I don’t know anywhere else you get them. However, if you are looking for actual jokes, this isn’t your thing. Timesuck is the best for that. I listen to both of them religiously.

I just recently stumbled upon your show and had to start from the very beginning! I’m HOOKED!

Small Town Murder is a unique podcast that explores murders that happened in small towns across the USA. I love the structure of the show, and James and Jimmy’s hilarious commentary. Together, it makes for an easy to follow story that always leaves you wanting more. The best part of the show is James and Jimmy’s genuine commitment to the show’s supporters.

I love STM!! I listen everyday at work, and it makes my workday 1000 time more tolerable!

This is it folks. This right here is the worst podcast I have ever had the opportunity to waste my time on. A couple of blow hards that like to hear themselves speak about nothing. This is the one. I spent 33 minutes on a podcast and they never even started talking about the case. Super disrespectful to the town it was based in and made fun of the type of people that must have lived there. 0/10. Don’t waste your time. I’d rather listen to paint dry.

Keep up the great work

Really enjoy the podcast I end up laughing, but in the best way and hearing true crime murder stories, which I love! I love both of the guys sense of humor. I’m actually gonna go and order the live show they did on 4/20 to watch.

This is my “go to” podcast!

The condescending attitude of these hosts while they read the wiki notes or other people’s research about each town is off putting. All it took was listening to an episode about a town I’ve lived in to realize they know NOTHING about the towns then are talking about, they can’t pronounce it, they don’t know what the people do, they make up stuff that isn’t true about the town at all.

I’ve been listening to this and C.I.S since the beginning and once caught up I’ve gone back and listened to the episodes all over again. The support has gained James health insurance, yaaaay! Great show, worth a listen if curious but know what you’re getting into.

I could look up the demographic details of the small towns without their condescending remarks. The storylines are discussed with no research other than a quick and easy google search. Save the time it takes to listen to them and do a quick 5 minute read via google.

Jimmie, even though you pronounced my first name wrong you pronounced my last name perfectly!!!! Love you guys!!!